Double-T Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Kicking it with Kirk Herbstreit Bar-right-arrows



A blogger is a blogger is a blogger.

Mark Cuban has an interesting post on bloggers in the Dallas Mavericks locker room. As Cuban tells the story, DMN's blogger Tim MacMahon was denied access to the locker room because he was only a blogger, but is not a part of the print media, thus Cuban denied him access to the locker room. Cuban did continue to allow him to have access to the press conferences, just not the locker room.

The DMN's response was this:

" Gilbert Bailon, president of the American Society of Newspaper Editors, says blogging is now "part of the base job of being a beat reporter" at a newspaper. He acknowledges your need/right to control press credentials but thinks you're off base when it comes to banning bloggers from major news organizations from your locker room. He says this seems like a policy aimed at one reporter, Tim MacMahon, because he wrote something you didn't like. (Note: Bailon is editor of the editorial page at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and previously was a top editor at The Morning News.)"

I think that's pretty much the gist of the story. The DMN is claiming that MacMahon is being banned because of something he wrote, while Cuban is saying that he's banned MacMahon because he's just a blogger. For the most part, I agree with Cuban here. MacMahon is just a blogger. Although he does an excellent job of covering most of the local sports and being opinionated (although I tend to think he's opinionated, just to be opinionated), including for the DMN College Blog, he is now just a blogger. As a guy who would love to go to press conferences or inside the locker room, I think there is little to zero chance that I ever get the opportunity to do this not because I'm not a good writer, or because I don't have a decent pedigree, but because I'm just a blogger. I am lucky enough to have an incredible platform at SB Nation, just as MacMahon is at the DMN, but what makes him any different than me? The paycheck? (I do make some money off of blogging, so again, what's the difference?)

I also like how Bailon differentiates between bloggers as beat writers from newspapers versus bloggers who blog just because they love their respective team. Of course, I'm not sure if anyone has asked, but the Dallas Mavericks has their own blogger/writer in Art Garcia, Mavs Courtside View, and I'm almost positive he's full-time with the Mavericks. Is he allowed inside the locker room?

Besides the actual blogger v. writer argument, this does make a ton of sense for from a logistical standpoint. Imagine that you are part of the Mavs' P.R. department and you've got 100 guys and gals, all claiming to be Dallas Maverick bloggers and all of them want access to the locker room. That's a problem. I'd imagine that if any team, collegiate or professional, opened up their doors if you were a blogger, then those same doors would come crashing down with every fan claiming that they should be granted access.

Something else to think about. Fellow Texas Tech blogger, RaiderAde essentially blogs for the Houston Chronicle. RaiderAde has a major newspaper platform, what makes him any different that MacMahon, again, besides the paycheck?

I suppose all of this could easily be solved if MacMahon just started writing for the print side of the newspaper. And by the way, I like Tim, he's also talked with DTN on a couple of occasions and been more than willing to give up his time to email back and forth with me and not every newspaper guy will do this.

I've never thought that I should have access to any sort of Texas Tech events. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to have the access, but that access can be denied as easily as it was provided and if I choose to write something about the team or a player that doesn't paint him or her in a favorable light, then I can probably kiss that access goodbye.

Besides, I figure that if you want news, you have outlets. I keep thinking that my "job" is to provide you the hub to access that information (links) and actually take the time to provide a little deeper analysis (this typically comes after basketball season, when there's not so much going on) of the team we love.

Any of your thoughts on the matter are greatly appreciated.

0 recs | Comment 3 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Agreed
A paycheck would be nice, or locker room access, I wouldn't be picky about which.  I agree with Cuban, though, and that's the first time in my life I think I've ever said that.

I almost wish he'd reverse his decision and set some sort of precedent, though.

It's an interesting case in the evolution of print media, for sure.

by ayleein on Mar 11, 2008 1:27 AM CDT   0 recs

New Media
As a former sports journalist, I think all media members saw this problem coming. What draws the line in the sand between online journalist and blogger? At a recent tradeshow in the new industry I work in, bloggers were admitted separate passes into a major electronics tradeshow and allowed to ask questions and interact with major companies similar to print, broadcast and online journalists. For the most part, everything went fine. There are bloggers out there with large followings that respected their power, but there were a select few that gave bloggers a bad name. Several bloggers were pulling pranks on unsuspecting companies like ruining presentations, writing horrible reviews and abusing their privileged power. Tim MacMahon answers to his editors and publishers at the Dallas Morning News and Belo Corporation ... a blogger like Perez Hilton normally wouldn't answer to anyone. I think unleashing bloggers on a major league sports locker room is a horrible idea. While Tim might be called a blogger, he's in fact considered an online journalist -- a profession now taught at most major journalism schools including Texas Tech. If the online journalist is affiliated with a major news source, the access should be granted. His views on the Web site reflect the same criteria and editorial criticism given to print columns by Tim Cowlishaw or Randy Galloway -- Tim's words are just found in a different location.  
Wreck 'em Tech!

by Phillyred Raider on Mar 11, 2008 3:15 PM CDT   0 recs

Cuban
He's nothing more than a petulant brat. A very rich brat, but a brat none the less.

by Tech92 on Mar 11, 2008 8:34 PM CDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Texas Tech Red Raiders.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
My Top 25 End Week 6
Small
I hope Tech Defense reads this quote
Small
My End of Week 5 BCS End of Season prediction
Small
My Top 25 end week 5
Small
our ranking
Small
What have we learned - the defense
Larry_at_fiest_texas_small
USC
Small
Vote for Graham Harrell for the Davey O'Brien Award
Img_0600_small
Many Texas fans like our style....
Small
Preseason is Over

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Uniwatch_sethc_jersey_small Seth C

ad

Site Meter